Kent State Shootings Expert
  • The Story of the Kent State Shootings
  • Conclusions & New Information
  • Book Reviews
  • Was There a Conspiracy to Fire?
  • The Forgotten Heroes
  • The Story Behind the Book
  • Blog
  • Links
  • Q&A with WAG
  • Bibliography
  • Chronology
  • Buy e-Book
  • Contact
  • The Story of the Kent State Shootings
  • Conclusions & New Information
  • Book Reviews
  • Was There a Conspiracy to Fire?
  • The Forgotten Heroes
  • The Story Behind the Book
  • Blog
  • Links
  • Q&A with WAG
  • Bibliography
  • Chronology
  • Buy e-Book
  • Contact

The Proposed Kent State Movie: Did Howard Means Plagiarize My Book on Kent State?

10/25/2017

0 Comments

 
A year and half ago, when I let Howard Means off the hook for plagiarizing my book, (http://kentstatedevelopments.blogspot.com/), I was inexplicably thinking that he had to have copied my text word to word in order to  be guilty of plagiarism. I do not know why I thought that. Perhaps I did not want to believe he was capable of theft . . . or maybe I did not want to make a big issue of it. We are, after all, competitors and anyone who knows anything about the cesspool that May 4 has become would understand that he did not hurt me as much as others have. 

In any event, after I was reintroduced to the Chicago Manual of Style, it appears that I was wrong about Means. The Manual's guidelines suggest he did in fact steal from my work without crediting my original reporting.

Section 4.85 of the Manual, which defines what constitutes fair use and what constitutes plagiarism, states:

"With all reuse of others' materials, it is important to identify the original as the source. This not only bolsters the claim of fair use but also helps avoid any accusation of plagiarism. Nothing elaborate is required: a standard footnote will suffice."

Means used no such footnote in passing off my research as if it were his own. Last year, in my blog post of April 6, 2016, I noted that on page 43 of his book Means basically lifted  from what I wrote about in the updated e-book edition of Four Dead in Ohio published a year earlier. 

In my book (Kindle location 414-450), I cited my sources in reporting that two individuals had finally admitted to being involved in the destruction of the university ROTC building on May 2, 1970. two days before the killings. Before that, no one had ever admitted being responsible for the arson (although I did report in the original hardcover edition of my book (1990) that one of the individuals involved, the late George Walter Harrington, was prominently mentioned in memos sent to and from FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover. If you will forgive my footnote fetish, I raised the question as to why Harrington was never indicted, especially since he admitted to the FBI that he played a key intermediary role in the initial attempts to burn ROTC down).

Instead of revealing how he came across this information, Means cited only "an anonymous source" in identifying the second arsonist, Thomas "Aquinas" Miller. I first reported about Miller, citing a report in an unrelated book (Fortney Road) which reported Miller's subsequent involvement in a cult. 

Means' claim that he used "an anonymous source" does not withstand the smell test. Journalists typically grant anonymity when they have to protect whistleblowers who might be fired if their identifies were publicly revealed. Kent State, on the other hand, is strictly an historical event.

In this case, both of individuals involved in the arson (Harrington and Miller) have been dead for over 30 and 40 years. There was no compelling reason for anyone to ask for anonymity, or for Means to grant it. Given that I was the first to link Harrington to Miller and write about them together a year before the Means' came out, it strains credulity to believe that Means' "anonymous source" was anything other than my book.

The Chicago Manual makes it clear that an author (Means) cannot take "a free ride on the first author's labor." I also noted in my blog that Means' work as a whole was far less original than his book seemed to suggest. In the final analysis, he did not break any new ground but essentially seconded more than 20 conclusions I reached 26 years earlier. 

And what could be more suspicious than the fact that Means pretended my exhaustive research did not exist? Means never once cited my book in his source notes and even excluded it in his selected bibliography. That bibliography, by the way, cites every other other essential book on May 4, 1970. As I wrote last year: "it was almost as if he did not want anyone to compare his book with mine." Means also wrote as if no previous May 4 author came before him.

I am sure Means will come up with some excuse, as if a 70-something-year-old author of over ten books did not know that plagiarism is the most serious journalistic sin a journalist or popular historian can commit.

This issue suddenly became important again after the announcement that producer/director Jay Roach intends to turn Means book, 67 Shots, into a motion picture using the same title as Means. The proposed movie is being packaged by Roach's production company. Other producers include Tina Fey and her composer husband, Jeff Richmond, a graduate of Kent State. 
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    ​This blog is written by William A. Gordon, a Kent State alumnus and the author of "Four Dead in Ohio" and three other books. It offers commentary on the still unfolding developments in the Kent State shooting case.

    Picture

    Archives

    March 2020
    August 2019
    April 2019
    October 2017
    December 2016
    April 2016
    July 2015
    April 2014
    April 2013
    October 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    December 2011
    August 2011
    April 2011

    Categories

    All
    67 Shots
    Above The Shots
    Alan Canfora
    Allison Krause
    Arthur Krause
    Bob Gage
    Charles Deegan
    Cleveland Plain Dealer
    COINTELPRO
    Dean Kahler
    Death And Dissent In The Long Sixties
    Devo
    Fortney Road
    Four Dead In Ohio
    George Walter Harrington
    Gregory Rambo
    Greg Payne
    Howard Means
    Jay Roach
    Jeffrey Miller
    Jeff Richmond
    Jerry Casale
    Jerry M Lewis
    John Darnell
    John E Martin
    John Fitzgerald O'Hara
    John Mangels
    Judge Frank Battisti
    Kent Krazies
    Kent May 4 Center
    Kent May 4 Central
    Kent State
    Kent State 50th Anniversary Commemoration
    Kent State Commemoration
    Kent State Killings
    Kent State Movie
    Kent State Murders
    Kent State ROTC Building
    Kent State Shootings
    Kent State Tragedy
    Kent State University
    Laura Davis
    Lesley Wischmann
    Major Harry Jones
    Matthew McManus
    May 4 1970
    May 4 1970 Killings
    May 4 Visitors Center
    Moments Of Truth
    Myron Pryor
    Ohio National Guard
    Paul Keane
    Philip Caputo
    Raymond Srp
    Ron Snyder
    Stuart Allen
    Terry Norman
    Terry Strubbe
    The Man Who Started The Killings At Kent State
    The May 4 Shootings At Kent State University
    Thomas "Aquinas" Miller
    Thomas Grace
    Tina Fey
    Tom Masterson
    Tom Owen
    William A Gordon

    RSS Feed

Kent State Shooting Expert
William A. Gordon
​Email:  BGordonLA@aol.com
​Website:  www.KentStateShootingsExpert.com
Copyright © Kent State Shooting Expert. All Rights Reserved
Website Design by WCW Designs
Picture
Contact
Visit Blog
Buy E-Book